When thinking of the Great Powers
of the world, some easily ready names come to mind. Obviously the United
States, Great Britain, Russia perhaps, and as of recently—China. Yes, as the
years have progressed, China has transformed from a strict powerless communist
state in the international realm, to an economic powerhouse. AS China has begun
to gain more and more power, especially within their region, they have also had
the ability to evoke more influence towards other states in the world. It is
this influence, based both on their rising economy and size that has seen China
emerge as a possible threat to some of the Great Powers of the world. Yet some
still argue whether China is a truly “Great” Power. A number of people may say
that China lacks the ability to be classified as a Great Power because of the
primitive state of their military capabilities. However, I would argue that the
potential for China’s military might to match that of Russia and some of the
other Great Powers is growing. China, with their growing economy and massive
population will easily be able to create an advanced standing army in the
future capable of allowing them to be labeled as a Great Power. Even today, we
can see that this evolution of China’s military power and economy is putting pressure
on other Great Powers. In the U.S. specifically, leaders and the public are
worried about China’s growth. They are worried that as China grows stronger and
their economy grows bigger, that they will soon challenge the U.S. as the world
hegemon. While all of this may be true, can China be classified as a Great
Power? Or are they simply threatening the norms of the other Great Powers?
If
one is looking at whether to classify China as a Great Power or not, they must
first ask the question of what qualifies as being a Great Power. Is it military
capabilities? Is it Economic Prosperity? Is it having a public that is well
cared for and is able to live comfortably? Or is it rather a combination of all
of these that would create a state that is a Great Power. After these questions
are asked, it has to be determined whether or not Chinas has acquired (or can
acquire) all of these. In terms of economic prosperity, China has clearly
proven that they are a global superpower. Militarily, China has the potential
to create one of the largest fighting forces in the world. However, if you are
gauging whether or not China is a Great Power based on the advancement and
welfare of its people, then they are clearly not there. Yet, in my own view,
the way a state’s people live does not matter in terms of whether they are a
Great Power or not. It is clear that China has begun to pose a threat to some
of the other Great Powers because of their growing power—an idea that would be
supported by a realist. This threat is not unheeded. As a Great Power, China
may be able to have more influence over world policies. Not all of this
influence may be in line with the ideals of the other Great Powers—a situation that
poses the greatest threat. Yet with China already a part of the group, the
other Great Powers will have to quickly adjust to respond to the Chinese.
The three main classifications that you point out about what makes a powerful country a "great" power are key. Economic, military and social welfare are what determine how power the country is in the view of the rest of the world. I agree with you that their economy has clearly proven to be great, and their military has extreme potential, but I think that a lot of people would also think that the social welfare is just as important as the other two in determining how great of a power it really can be. People need to support the government in order for it to be the most successful it can possibly be.
ReplyDeleteI agree that states classified as Great Powers are usually tailored around a few questions. I believe military might and economic wealth are probably two of the main reasons. These would be considered a state's hard powers. China's cultural extends back hundreds of years. This has left a longer presence of Chinese culture for the rest of the world, which has influenced society in a number of ways. This is it's soft power which is also a large amount of power to be held by a state.
ReplyDelete